SkirtedMarine,
Your response seemed to be at least 85% if not 90% rant, and a repeating of the problems. I asked for solutions not a repeat of the problems.
I wasn't being sarcastic when I said I didn't know what to do, I really don't. But what I do see is a failure on both sides in regards to compassion and compromise. Both sides, far right and far left want it all their way, and neither side is compassionate towards the other.
Your reply would make a politician proud, it said a lot without saying hardly anything meaningful at all. It was an masterpiece of passive aggression peppered with little jabs at liberals. I doubt Trump could have done it any better!
BTW: Please don't pigeonhole me in some political agenda, liberal, conservative, or otherwise. I have no allegiance to any party or agenda, my views are centered on
reason, respect, tolerance, and compassion. In that order.
But anyway, lets dissect the reply:
skirtedMarine wrote:I'm just a dumbass, old retired Marine
I don't think you're a dumbass at all. I understand a lot of what you are saying, and have shared many of your rants over the years. You seem to have put a lot of thought into your convictions, and nobody is wrong 100% of the time. Everybody deserves a time to speak. Many aspects of the country you served is going to hell in a handbasket, you of all people are somewhat entitled to be a little pissed off.
And thank you for your service to our country by the way. With your service abroad you have a unique understanding of the world that many of us who have never done so would lack, and so yes I personally read with interest and an open mind to your responses... even if you do think I'm a flaming liberal.
skirtedMarine wrote:ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION
Not a hard issue,
1.Iliminate the "Anchor baby " loophole
2. Enforce the laws that we already have.I'll not rub the current administrations lawlessness in the face of You who think We shouldnt have boarders. So they can get more Democrat voters...
3. Stop changing the language from "Illegal Immigrants "
To "Undocumented" Citizens, (They are not entitled to our healthcare, welfare, free education, or even the right to work here. At 20 trillion in debt, We can't afford to let them bring their corruption, gangs, Drugs, crime and so on, Just so they'll be registered Democrats.
4 . They broke the law by entering the United States Illegally, (So Get out, and take your anchor baby with you!)
No. 1) Okay... baby pops out stateside... send him/her back south. Fair enough
No. 2) Which laws? Who said exactly that we "shouldn't have borders"? While we're sending back illegals, do you think that all Anglo Saxon citizens should pack up and go back to our European nation of origin? What exactly gives any one class the any more right over another to occupy a piece of the planet? This question isn't rhetorical... it's genuine... think about it.
No. 3) Fair enough.
No. 4) Didn't really address anything different that wasn't covered in the first three.
So I'm left to assume that you think anyone who isn't a naturalized citizen needs to get out. Okay, fair enough. Who's going to fill all those cheap labor positions that open up? A U.S. worker? What policy can you enact to prevent runaway cost as farmers, contractors, etc must resort to employing legal citizens even at the minimum wage, subject to labor law, unemployment insurance, liability, etc. Again, not rhetorical. This is the can of worms we open... I'm genuinely curious as to how we will deal with it.
skirtedMarine wrote:POVERTY
IT is, and always has been with us, please understand, We as Americans did depend on our Churches to be our Welfare board, Our Marraige Councilor, Our Pregnancy Counceling clinic, Through our Churches, In Whatever our faith,, We all pitched in, and did the right thing,
1.I'LL MAINTAIN THAT ANYTHING YOU LET THE GOVERNMENT CONTROL, IT WILL TURN TO CRAP AT TEN TIMES THE COST, WITH FAMILIES GENERATION AFTER GENERATION LIVING OFF OF THE BACKS OF THE TAX PAYERS...
First section (the non caps part): Sounds like a perfect world scenario. Tell me, if it worked so well, how did we devolve into having the government needing to step in? I seem to recall stories of things getting pretty ugly in the crash of '29 prior to all those modern day welfare programs. When we allow the church say in our lives in regards to marriage and pregnancy counseling, what prevents us as a society from slipping into a similar situation that society faced in the dark ages? Who will be an advocate for the heathen, the atheist, the homosexual, the transgendered? Are they just SOL because they might not necessarily follow the doctrine of the Christian Church?
Second section: (the part in caps) Can't really argue with that. Although a lot of government's problems is the constant stale mates we find ourselves in, and brings policy making to a stand still. Nobody is willing to compromise at all.
skirtedMarine wrote:LGBT RIGHTS
OK, I'll go there
So I've lived in the Middle East, have you noticed that the immigrants from anywhere in the UAE Arent interested in becoming Americans? Their "Religion" is their government, And they bring their Understanding of it with them, This is a culture that Allowes Men to rape boys,( but They're not really gay) This is a culture that cuts the Clitorous off of a girl because women are not allowed to enjoy sex, This is a culture that requires 4 male wittnesses to prosicute a man for rape of a woman
This is also a culture that will kill men for bieng gay, with a man unless it was a boy. Or a goat, Sorry , Where else in the world do the LGBT folks have more rights than the Straight Small buisness bakery? Why do you folks on the left make it a problem? Again, too many GD Lawyers, and 90% of them are so called indoctrinated "Liberals".
What does any of that have to do with the LGBT issue here state side?
I
have noticed that in the middle east, their religion is their government. I also notice it here too. Just a different religion. Pro-right Christian zealots may not be cutting the heads off of homosexuals or transgendered people, but they sure don't make it easy to function in society. There are NO federal prohibitions on LGBT discrimination. For those who say such a lifestyle is a choice and they should "choose" to live a more "moral" (Christian) lifestyle, I submit that religion too is a choice. If a employer should be allowed to terminate someone for their sexual/gender orientation... then why not be allowed to terminate based on religion as well? Further, why stop at LGBT discrimination, why not go all the way and follow the Bible to the letter? Why pick and choose what we discriminate over? If one has a tattoo, eats pork, commits adultery, is on a second marriage, etc lets kill them!
Where do we draw the line? Again, not rhetorical. Where
do we draw the line? Why should a cake baker who is on her third marriage, has a tattoo on her arm, eats bacon sandwiches turn a homosexual away? What does baking a cake have to do with Christianity anyway? How does she (the baker) know that her supplies weren't delivered by a homosexual? How does she know that the bacon sandwich she ate for lunch at McDonalds wasn't prepared by someone who's transgender? Maybe people who are that fundimental should just drop out of the American economy and live in some sort of a evangelical commune. At least then they wouldn't sound like such a hypocrite.
skirtedMarine wrote:Gun Rights
We have a Constitution,
Ive been a responsible gun owner since I was 16 years old, and I even have an AR 15, (what you people call an "Assault Weapon", Gun rights, .... ?" The right of the people to keep and bare arms shall not be infringed" . The guns arent the problem, Society has become the problem, Its like saying "The spoon makes people fat"
Again, Boarders, Language, Culture...Why are all the mass shootings done by Democrats, And GD Muslims?
Fair enough... but are you suggesting that law biding Democrats and law biding Muslims who are U.S. citizens shouldn't have the same right? And where do we draw the line on what's an acceptable weapon for ordinary citizens to own? Should I be allowed to own a nuclear warhead?
Another common denominator among mass shootings is that the guns involved are almost ALWAYS obtained legally. So how will relaxing gun laws solve that?
Now let me just say, that
I'm pro-2nd.
Go back and re-read that...
I'm PRO GUN. But I'm simply looking at the issue critically. It's not white and black.
It's a complicated issue. You offered no solutions, you simply blamed liberals. Remember, you're the president! How will relaxing gun laws keep firearms out of the hands of killers with no criminal history? How will you tell the good guys from the bad ones? How do you know I'm not planning a massacre as we speak? I've never even had a speeding ticket, but I could be a ISIS sympathizer, how would you be able to tell? (I'm not by the way... STAND DOWN NSA)
skirtedMarine wrote:"Terrorism"
Stop unlimited Immigration,
Its about to get alot worse, Get over it, Trump has this one right!
See my notes above....
skirtedMarine wrote:Religious freedom"
A hard subject if you think that Islam is an actual religion rather than a political idology. Otherwise, We have a first amendment, and its covered, and not confusing. You can believe in the door knob if you so chose, but don't insist that I do or call me an "infidel " and try to kill me if I refuse to believe what you believe.
Through the middle ages, Christianity could have been considered a political ideology. To this day, in some ways it still is as it plays a big role in our secular law making process. Your response didn't really tackle any current issues. Let me be more clear....
the turning away of people from your SECULAR business who don't align with your religious views?
skirtedMarine wrote:Healthcare
Its not the Governments job ( again, everything the government touches turns to crap!)
So runaway profits of the health care industry is okay? Millions of healthcare bankruptcies are acceptable? So are you advocating a complete de-regulation of all things health care? Tell me how that is going to benefit anyone but those who are wealthy enough to afford it?
skirtedMarine wrote:I hope you got at least a chuckle out of my response,
It's been a hoot!
