What would you like to see in a man's dress?

General discussion of skirt and kilt-based fashion for men, and stuff that goes with skirts and kilts.
Post Reply
User avatar
crfriend
Master Barista
Posts: 15178
Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 9:52 pm
Location: New England (U.S.)
Contact:

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by crfriend »

Note: This is written from the perspective of an individual contributor, not a moderator.
SkirtedViking wrote:Hens must be compared to hens,roosters to roosters!
That's an interesting thesis, especially when juxtaposed with:
SkirtedViking wrote:There is nothing worse than double standard!
So, which is it? Pick one. Either will do.

In any event, my criticism was aimed at the way the garment looked on the subject, not about comparing the aesthetic "value" of men versus women. It's not a "hens versus roosters" notion, it's a "what works on whom" notion. Women and men are built differently: that's just plain biology. It also tends to dictate what sorts of styles "work" best for either. Very androgenous types can likely get away with whatever they want from whatever "side of the aisle" they see fit; folks with more differentiated body-types likely cannot. (OK, "cannot" may be too strong; perhaps it'd be better to say that "they can, but will likely look strange".)

Personally, I'd love to see "unified garments" (in addition to jumpsuits) designed for guys, and there is historical precedent for same, viz robes, tunics, and togas. This is a design type that can be mastered, but I'll posit that it's not going to be done so by raiding our sisters' closets.

By the by, JohnH, good luck on taming the waistline and associated maladies -- if attraction to a particular garment helps in that regard, then the whole enterprise is full of win.
Retrocomputing -- It's not just a job, it's an adventure!
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

If you read thoroughly the discussion there are parallels made between how the dress fits John and the female model.
Double standard in my signature means that a woman in all MASCULINE attire and shoes is considered normal while the opposite not - humans must have equal rights of self expression no matter gender.I claim that males can wear most styles of female tops and look nice. Some of the tops are influenced also by former male fashion from the past centuries and even antiquity.Some are not of course but that cannot prevent males from wearing them.Female upper clothing in most cases is aimed to accentuate on the chest no matter the shape, so if you have good chest it can suit you.By judging on myself it looks good and certainly different compared to a woman.When you stop comparing that you will find the idea acceptable and bringing equality.When you wear a "masculine" skirt and still some folks outside make a comparison how it fits you and how it would look like on a woman it is not a good feeling.There come the comments:A woman looks better,this is just for women,or man do not have the legs etc.We have different figures but must have the same rights and variety of styles,men also have beautiful bodies,especially when they work out.You think that all women look like the model?Hardly...
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
crfriend
Master Barista
Posts: 15178
Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 9:52 pm
Location: New England (U.S.)
Contact:

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by crfriend »

SkirtedViking wrote:If you read thoroughly the discussion there are parallels made between how the dress fits John and the female model.

Double standard in my signature means that a woman in all MASCULINE attire and shoes is considered normal while the opposite not [...]
It's rather clear that we're on different wavelengths here; I was writing about the way a garment is tailored, and you seem to be arguing for full equality. In principle, I support the latter, but I'd really like to see the former paid attention to as well. If you look closely, most womens trousers of today (other than dungarees, which are truly unisex) bear only a passing nod in tailoring to the mens variety; it is a style that women have adopted, and made their own by tailoring it to their own body types. That it does not currently go the other way seems more to point up that most guys just don't care than anything else.
When you wear a "masculine" skirt and still some folks outside make a comparison how it fits you and how it would look like on a woman it is not a good feeling.
Other than the kilt and sarong-type garments, show me a skirt specifically constructed for men that does not look either like a parody by going overboard on "masculine detail" or is made from heavy denim. They do not seem to exist at the moment (Note: I have not seen the H&M one yet.), so we are forced to wear, and possibly adapt, womens styles, and that creates for many a tailoring problem. Of course, the more adept of us make their own skirts, and in so doing, wind up with bespoke garments that fit their body type perfectly. Comparing what a garment looks like on a man to what it looks like on a woman is pointless; pointing up tailoring and fit problems -- so they might be fixed -- should be fair game.
We have different figures but must have the same rights and variety of styles,men also have beautiful bodies,especially when they work out.
I concur with this, and I'd also point out that it's not necessarily a requirement to work out to have a decent body. Too, there are quite a few male body-types, and I believe it's important that clothes be properly cut and tailored for each of them; we all lose in the modern "one size fits most" mentality. Just try buying a shirt that doesn't fit like a tent at anything like a normal price.

As has always been the case anyway, beauty is -- and always will be -- in the eye of the beholder.
You think that all women look like the model?Hardly...
I'm actually impressed that they used a model that has hips and curves for the photo-shoot. Most of what passes for models these days are Kate Moss heroin-chic knock-offs that look like cadavers with slab sides; one of the reasons I suspect that the photo garnered the number of hits that it did is that the shot resembles (more or less) reality. Most of us -- men and women -- are a bit too "plus-sized" for our own good anyway; shaming us (or trying to) by holding us up to waif-like anorexics I feel is not just counterproductive but dangerous as it introduces hopelessness ("I can never look like that!") and causes folks to not even try to stay in anything resembling physical shape. (Of course there is the old quip, "I am in shape. Round is a shape.")
Retrocomputing -- It's not just a job, it's an adventure!
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

It is certainly a very nice discussion where we can share our views and opinions.I can only add,that I have a typical male body and wear skirts without tailoring and they fit me.Probably I pick models that are made for not so curvy body,but most of my skirts are with a high waist and have no problem with that,no empty spaces in the hips.About tops it is the same,without altering and picking correct ones they fit me in a male way.
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
crfriend
Master Barista
Posts: 15178
Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 9:52 pm
Location: New England (U.S.)
Contact:

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by crfriend »

SkirtedViking wrote:It is certainly a very nice discussion where we can share our views and opinions.
That's one of the things that I like best about this community.
I can only add,that I have a typical male body and wear skirts without tailoring and they fit me.Probably I pick models that are made for not so curvy body [...]
I find that styles from the "juniors" or "misses" departments typically fit me better than those from the "womens"; this is likely because the former body-type is closer to my own (less curves) than the latter. Sometimes some gentle adaptation, though, is required.
About tops it is the same,without altering and picking correct ones they fit me in a male way.
These can be had (I have two) and look good, but it's a bit more difficult to actually get a good fit than it is with skirts -- at least in my experience. In my case, I usually have to go up a size to accommodate my shoulders, and this can create problems in the chest and waist areas.

As far as John's dress goes, I'm looking forward to seeing how the look changes as he "shrinks into it".
Retrocomputing -- It's not just a job, it's an adventure!
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

These can be had (I have two) and look good, but it's a bit more difficult to actually get a good fit than it is with skirts -- at least in my experience. In my case, I usually have to go up a size to accommodate my shoulders, and this can create problems in the chest and waist areas.
Hum,really never had this kind of problem-probably because I prefer elastic and stretchy materials in most cases and when the material is less elastic, I pick models which require the fabric to be loose and thus way it looks also great.
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
JRMILLER
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 711
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2007 6:52 pm
Location: Delaware, Ohio

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by JRMILLER »

In terms of "preference", the "shirtdress from Metro" posted by jazbell is one of the few dresslike items that I think a guy could wear and let's say still defend themselves as a guy. JohnH's dress is clearly made for a woman and despite the fact that it "fits", it still looks like a woman's dress on a guy.

I feel we are all representatives of the "movement" to gain acceptance of skirted items for guys in our culture. I believe the skirtdress would be perceived positively, no doubt it would get some double takes, but still positively. JohnH's dress would probably be perceived as a guy who wants "to be" a woman or somehow appear as a woman. This may not be JohnH's goal in wearing that dress, but the less sophisticated rabble would probably perceive it this way.

I also agree that we should not be bending over backwards to please everyone else on the planet, but I do believe there is a middle ground that can be gained and that's where I try to operate with my public appearances.

My goal is to find skirted items I can wear as a guy and clearly look like a guy (or simply myself), as opposed to a guy perceived as trying to look like a woman. Or a guy clearly wearing something made for a woman. It's damn hard to do since most skirted items (with the exception of kilts and sarongs and such) are made for women. The shirtdress gives me hope and some ideas. That could work!
-John
______________________

You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself (Rick Nelson "Garden Party")
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

JRMILLER wrote:In terms of "preference", the "shirtdress from Metro" posted by jazbell is one of the few dresslike items that I think a guy could wear and let's say still defend themselves as a guy. JohnH's dress is clearly made for a woman and despite the fact that it "fits", it still looks like a woman's dress on a guy.

I feel we are all representatives of the "movement" to gain acceptance of skirted items for guys in our culture. I believe the skirtdress would be perceived positively, no doubt it would get some double takes, but still positively. JohnH's dress would probably be perceived as a guy who wants "to be" a woman or somehow appear as a woman. This may not be JohnH's goal in wearing that dress, but the less sophisticated rabble would probably perceive it this way.

I also agree that we should not be bending over backwards to please everyone else on the planet, but I do believe there is a middle ground that can be gained and that's where I try to operate with my public appearances.

My goal is to find skirted items I can wear as a guy and clearly look like a guy (or simply myself), as opposed to a guy perceived as trying to look like a woman. Or a guy clearly wearing something made for a woman. It's damn hard to do since most skirted items (with the exception of kilts and sarongs and such) are made for women. The shirtdress gives me hope and some ideas. That could work!
I disagree to these staments.The reason for male limitted fashion freedom is the same principle of trying to compress yourself with the type of items you wear.Most males that do not want skirts think in the same manner.You can still look like a guy no matter what you wear.Women do it all the time with male styled apparel.I do not think that John looks like a woman and you should compare him to men, not to women.A woman in guy's trousers and etc. generally does not look like the male in the same trousers,t-shirt,flat shoes and so on. Males who want to be "masculine" not in terms of their natural physique and through some kind of fashion visual psychology are still prevailing on the outside and guess what-they claim that trousers are the most comfortable.OF COURSE EVERY INDIVIDUAL HAS HIS/HER OPINION AND I RESPECT THIS RIGHT!
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
JRMILLER
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 711
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2007 6:52 pm
Location: Delaware, Ohio

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by JRMILLER »

SV,
Gee a simple "I disagree" with everything I wrote? Can you be more specific so we can have something to discuss?
-John
______________________

You see, ya can't please everyone, so ya got to please yourself (Rick Nelson "Garden Party")
User avatar
Milfmog
Moderator
Posts: 2233
Joined: Tue Jul 18, 2006 7:30 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by Milfmog »

I tend to agree that a shirt dress is probably going to be the easiest type for a guy to wear and not be seen by the mindless masses as a wannabe woman. That's no reason why folks braver than I should not wear other types of dress of course and I applaud those with the cajones to disregard how others see them, however my wife worries about what others think and I will not do anything to cause her distress (even if it is all in her mind).

I have tried several shirt dresses but hit the usual issues with the fit, ie if it fits above the waste it will be huge around my middle. In practice I have only found one shirt dress that I could even get my shoulders into and that was in a shop specialising in "plus sizes".

I would be happy to try a t-shirt dress or polo shirt type dress, again if I could find anything big enough to accommodate my outsize proportions. I reckon the inherent stretch / give of cotton jersey would make the T-shirt option the easiest to get to fit. Obviously these types of dress would be rather casual but I am struggling to even imagine a more formal dress style for a guy that does not look like a caricature.

Have fun,


Ian.
Do not argue with idiots; they will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
Cogito ergo sum - Descartes
Cogito cogito ergo cogito sum - Ambrose Bierce
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

JRM,I think that I replied to the whole bulk of your statements.We have different points of view,no problem with that. Our common problem is social acceptance - the braver you are, the more social pressure you get unfortunately.BUT...more brave males shall lead to a faster change of social perceptions for both general types of non-trouser male wearers (BH and FS) that do not belong to the infamous CD/TV communities.if you wear even the most feminine garment or shoes and you act as a normal guy,not as a female impersonator and do not put fake stuff...and now imagine thousands of such men on the street.TV/CD soon shall vanish, they will be of no interest to anyone.As female CD/TV have almost thoroughly disappeared even as a term.No one calls a woman a transvestite(means crossdresser in Latin) even in straight male clothes and shoes when she walks down the street.There are many of them in my country - I live in Eastern Europe.And I am not talking about lesbians,many straight women do that and why not, no social scorn applied.They even try to convince us how comfortable male clothes are and how is much easier to be a guy because you do not have to choose and all that bulls*it.Not to have a choice is not an advantage...
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
crfriend
Master Barista
Posts: 15178
Joined: Fri Nov 19, 2004 9:52 pm
Location: New England (U.S.)
Contact:

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by crfriend »

Milfmog wrote:I have tried several shirt dresses but hit the usual issues with the fit, ie if it fits above the waste it will be huge around my middle. In practice I have only found one shirt dress that I could even get my shoulders into and that was in a shop specialising in "plus sizes".
This is that nasty fact of biological differences between the sexes raising its ugly head again -- and it's something that we're not going to be able to make go away by whimpering about how "unfair" it is. Life is unfair -- almost by definition -- so those who whimper should just knock it off and let those who don't get on with things.

Dresses are going to be a very difficult "sell" to men -- and that's because they're going to have to be tailored to mens sizes and frames, and there's precisely nothing in the modern idiom on which to build. I've seen shirtdresses (albeit on women) that would likely work fantastically well -- with the proper tailoring, that is -- on guys. One immediate problem I can see, however, is that more and more guys are carrying things on their belts (cell phones, pagers, &c.) and those could well be missing from a shirtdress.
I would be happy to try a t-shirt dress or polo shirt type dress, again if I could find anything big enough to accommodate my outsize proportions. I reckon the inherent stretch / give of cotton jersey would make the T-shirt option the easiest to get to fit. Obviously these types of dress would be rather casual but I am struggling to even imagine a more formal dress style for a guy that does not look like a caricature.
I tend to inhabit the more formal (or, at least, professional) realm, but have found that T-shirt dresses can work quite well due to their inherent stretchiness. Well, they do up to a point, and once that point's been reached they leave very little to the imagination, if you get my drift. I'll also note that this is not a style I would ever wear to work: it's just too casual.

I really should haul out and recommission Sapphire's sewing-machine, learn how to make a proper dress shirt (I need those anyway), and then modify the design to include a reasonably full skirt below. The overall effect would likely be close to several of the rigs I have now where the skirt colour(s) almost identically match the shirt colour(s); this look, interestingly, is known as a "two-piece dress".
Retrocomputing -- It's not just a job, it's an adventure!
User avatar
JohnH
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 1312
Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2010 12:46 am
Location: Irving, (DFW area) Texas USA

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by JohnH »

SkirtedViking wrote:JRM,I think that I replied to the whole bulk of your statements.We have different points of view,no problem with that. Our common problem is social acceptance - the braver you are, the more social pressure you get unfortunately.BUT...more brave males shall lead to a faster change of social perceptions for both general types of non-trouser male wearers (BH and FS) that do not belong to the infamous CD/TV communities.if you wear even the most feminine garment or shoes and you act as a normal guy,not as a female impersonator and do not put fake stuff...and now imagine thousands of such men on the street.TV/CD soon shall vanish, they will be of no interest to anyone.As female CD/TV have almost thoroughly disappeared even as a term.No one calls a woman a transvestite(means crossdresser in Latin) even in straight male clothes and shoes when she walks down the street.There are many of them in my country - I live in Eastern Europe.And I am not talking about lesbians,many straight women do that and why not, no social scorn applied.They even try to convince us how comfortable male clothes are and how is much easier to be a guy because you do not have to choose and all that bulls*it.Not to have a choice is not an advantage...
When I am out walking in my dress I make it a point to walk like a man - large steps where I lean into every step, as opposed to the girly short steps and the swinging of the hips. I even take relatively large steps with shoes with 4 inch heels (although I don't make it a habit to walk with such high heels). It also helps that I have a deep voice to greet people. I have absolutely no use for fake boobs and the like. So I definitely do NOT try to pass as a woman!

Women simply do not understand the discomfort of that wedge of cloth against the testicles. I have argued with my mother and wife, who say pants are more comfortable. I had to explain about that wedge.
I renounce the Great Male Renunciation!!!
SkirtedViking
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 278
Joined: Mon Nov 13, 2006 12:08 pm
Location: Europe

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by SkirtedViking »

I agree with you, well said.That was my point, to act like a regular guy,no matter what you wear.
There is nothing worse than double standard!
User avatar
JohnH
Member Extraordinaire
Posts: 1312
Joined: Wed Jun 23, 2010 12:46 am
Location: Irving, (DFW area) Texas USA

Re: What would you like to see in a man's dress?

Post by JohnH »

Milfmog wrote: I have tried several shirt dresses but hit the usual issues with the fit, ie if it fits above the waste it will be huge around my middle. In practice I have only found one shirt dress that I could even get my shoulders into and that was in a shop specialising in "plus sizes".
It's not surprising that you would have to try on plus-sized dresses. My dress is a plus-size, large. You could get a dress that fits your shoulders and then take in the sides to fit your body shape.

The only issue with my dress is that my gut sticks out too much and causes the elastic waist of the dress to stretch too far. I'm on a diet, and I have gone from 208 lbs down to 202.5 lbs. My gut does not stick out so far, and when I really try to suck it in (something I did not try for my picture) it is starting to look bit better. In an earlier posting I said I would put in additional elastic below the existing elastic but now I see that modification will be unnecessary.

When I get down to 195 lbs I will post another picture.
I renounce the Great Male Renunciation!!!
Post Reply