skirttron wrote:Since I find a sporran annoying and use a shoulder bag instead, I think the great flat redundant slab of material at the front is kind of ugly and frankly I would rather just have it pleated all round if that passed the Wife Test (it does not).
I'm not wild about sporrans, either! Especially those with tassles! The drumming drives one crazy! I think it was Hamish who suggested 'Blutak'!

I wish they had compartments, too!
skirttron wrote:Wool is also itchy and heavy and I feel kilts should be fully lined by default, since there is no merit in discomfort.
Well, you could buy a 'purposely designed' 'Kiltslip' or whatever they're called? Lining something that heavily pleated would add a small fortune to the price. Alternatively, pick up a cheap, a-line, plain 'slip' from
'the other side' - works just as well at a fraction of the price!
skirttron wrote:Tartan also has limited appeal as a design and I would prefer to have a few more choices, such as vertical stripes, to supplement the few modern designs available.
Blimey! There are hordes of different 'trad' variations, which must suit somebody. There are good choices in plain and I'm certain Hamish has one just like you describe. The only factor is the price......
