Uncle Al



If you can make changes or affect the change, concentrate on that.Barleymower wrote: ↑Fri Nov 10, 2023 6:08 pm I know. I feel the same BUT we can focus on things within society that are not working. They not working because they are wrong. Wrongs can be righted.
It’s interesting how many people on this site support freedom in so many ways except religion, which is allegedly the root of all evil. If I find time, I’ll make a better rebuttal. But as a starter, if religion is the number one thing to be eliminated , why are so many countries that eliminate religion still so repressive?
You think atheistic countries like Pol Pot's Cambodia and Stalin's USSR were repressive?greenboots wrote: ↑Sat Nov 11, 2023 5:08 pmIt’s interesting how many people on this site support freedom in so many ways except religion, which is allegedly the root of all evil. If I find time, I’ll make a better rebuttal. But as a starter, if religion is the number one thing to be eliminated , why are so many countries that eliminate religion still so repressive?
A lesson I'm still trying to learn, myself.STEVIE wrote: ↑Fri Nov 10, 2023 7:25 pmIf you can make changes or affect the change, concentrate on that.Barleymower wrote: ↑Fri Nov 10, 2023 6:08 pm I know. I feel the same BUT we can focus on things within society that are not working. They not working because they are wrong. Wrongs can be righted.
Life is easier when you accept that which you cannot, especially for your mental well being.
Steve.
It'd undeniably be a net positive, though. And "wishful thinking" is pretty much what this thread's, about, anyway.
Since when has anyone here discourage freedom of religion? Since when? That's a non-sequitur. Bashing religion doesn't automatically lead to telling people to stop worshipping whatever religion they want. Religion is brought up frequently here as a bad thing which needs to die in a pit fire because it STRIPS FREEDOM from other people, and has done so since its inception. It's one of the many push-backs against MiS — by people who want to control other people. It's no secret why many people here hate religion, and want to see it gone. It's just another chain that holds us, as a species, back.greenboots wrote: ↑Sat Nov 11, 2023 5:08 pmIt’s interesting how many people on this site support freedom in so many ways except religion, which is allegedly the root of all evil.
What is this? Many religious countries are repressive, themselves. Religiosity has nothing to do with how free or tyrannical a nation is.But as a starter, if religion is the number one thing to be eliminated , why are so many countries that eliminate religion still so repressive?
Precisely my point. Religiosity has little to do with whether someone is prejudiced against MiS. There are people who use their religion as a reason to judge others and people who use their religion as a motive to help others. Many cafe members belong to some faith community, mostly some flavour of Christianity. Some are perhaps very “religious” but as far as I can recall no member has faced serious animosity and most report either support or indifference as in the rest of society.
When I replied I referred to pointless "wishful thinking" and in fact that was pointless too.greenboots wrote: ↑Sat Nov 11, 2023 7:38 pm None of this is to deny that much harm has at times been done in the name of religion. But to suggest that if we got rid of religion the world would suddenly be a better place just doesn’t hold water.
Why muddy the waters over such a statement to begin with? It's also a weirdly-worded, vague one. Even the most atheistic countries still have people who are religious. Religion is diminishing, especially in more secular countries, but it isn't "eliminated" in any country. And what makes those more secular countries "repressive", per say?greenboots wrote: ↑Sat Nov 11, 2023 7:38 pmPrecisely my point. Religiosity has little to do with whether someone is prejudiced against MiS.
It's far more often the former, and less-so the latter. Shouldn't need a motive to help others, either, other than it's the right thing to do.There are people who use their religion as a reason to judge others and people who use their religion as a motive to help others.
That, I picked up on, as some members here are regular church-goers. My MiS example delves deeper than just simple intolerance of fashion choice, because religion tends to influence and reinforce gender roles on to people, motivated by the doctrine they may or may not even read, or have ever read in the first place. This targets people who subverts these roles, and that includes men wearing skirts, because "skirts are for girls/women".Many cafe members belong to some faith community, mostly some flavour of Christianity. Some are perhaps very “religious” but as far as I can recall no member has faced serious animosity and most report either support or indifference as in the rest of society.
A grave understatement if there ever was one. Not only has so much evil been done in the name of the religion, it has been used as a justification for horrific crimes against other people.None of this is to deny that much harm has at times been done in the name of religion.
The world surely would be a different place — I think we can both agree on that.But to suggest that if we got rid of religion the world would suddenly be a better place just doesn’t hold water.